Free to watch · In depth · Feelings
It Only Works One Way: where your feelings really come from
Keith Blevens44:15Recorded 2014
It Only Works One Way: where your feelings really come from
In 2014, Keith Blevens sat down in front of a camera to describe a logic that accounts for every feeling and every reality anyone has ever had: our feelings come from our thinking in the moment, and it only works one way. Starting from the move from a flat Earth to a round one, he sets two statements side by side, shows where suffering begins when we believe it works two ways, and walks through the implications: quieting down, living in the present moment, separate realities, facing life as it is, and a psychological North Star that can't be lost.
- “So this is a description, not a prescription, but a description.”
- “Now, the Earth was never flat, but we thought it was.”
- Two statements, and only one is true: “feelings are coming from our thinking about what is happening to us.”
- “And where that illogic starts is where your suffering begins.”
- “There's nothing you can do to separate thought from feeling.”
- His wife's question: “Well, does it seem to you that your feelings are coming from your thinking, or are they coming from what you're thinking about?”
- A profound safety, “because you can't feel anything you don't think.”
- “I realized that we were all in the same boat, and it was a beautiful boat.”
- “The thing doesn't bring the feeling.”
- “You are living in the feeling of your thinking.”
- “It can be forgotten, but it can't be lost.”
Reflection: Think of a feeling you had today. Was it coming from what was happening, or from your thinking about what was happening?
Transcribed by machine and corrected by a reader against the recording.
01A logic to the human experience00:00
I want to share with you a truth, a preexisting logic, that accounts for all of my feelings, all of my realities that I've been in, all of my experiences, and accounts for all of your experiences and all of your realities. So I want to talk about what, how that works, not what you should do about it, but how that works. How it is that we come to experience the experiences we experience. How it is that we come to feel the feelings that we feel.
What's the logic? There is a preexisting logic about the human experience that we've discovered. It's extremely important, extremely important for me, for anybody, for all of us. And I want to share that with you. I want to point that out.
I want to describe it. So this is a description, not a prescription, but a description. This is a logic. Because we've discovered a logic, one of the things that comes with a logic is that it exposes any illogic. It exposes its obverse or its reverse. So any time through the years, through all of human history, that a logic has been isolated, it has, we now know how that system works, and simultaneously, we know how it doesn't work.
That is really important for the human experience. This logic is unusurpable. It's unchangeable. It can't be manipulated. It's a constant. It's not a— It's not under my jurisdiction. It's the way something works systemically, universally, without any doing on our part.
It's always been here and always will be here. It's a constant of why people feel what they feel. Every time anybody sees such a constant, it speaks to them. When they have an insight about it, when they see it, not just intellectually, but see it, the truth of it, it speaks to them. It helps them.
It roots them. It stabilizes them. It gives them something that they know to be true, as true in the moment. So I'm going to practically explain, as best I can, what that is, what that experience is, and what's the logic behind it, this preexisting logic that will bring you, or bring all of us—it has been bringing all of us—back to itself.
And so that you can connect to it in your everyday life, and as you experience it and understand it and have more of it, you're going to—you're going to thrive rather than strive. You're going to connect rather than disconnect. You're going to feel more with it and more stable rather than out of it and confused and reactive. Guaranteed.
02From a flat Earth to a round Earth03:54
In my description here, and the relevance for you in your everyday life, I want to emphasize one point. I'm not telling you or talking to you about how you should think, or how you should feel, or what you should think, or what you should feel. I'm talking about a logic that explains your experience, explains my experience. So I'm not telling you what to do about that. This is not application.
This is about description and the implications of that logic and that description. I'm trying to describe how your thought and feeling actually work all the time as a constant. Now let me give you an example to kind of set the stage for this description, this preexisting logic. You know, we used to think the Earth was flat. It looked flat. It still looks flat to me.
The world lived in a flat world. We lived on a flat Earth for millennia. We didn't know that it was a sphere. It looked flat, and we assumed it was flat. All the models of the world, they all show a flat Earth.
And, we used to think that way, what people thought about, what they talked about, what they did when the Earth was flat was very different than what people thought about and talked about and did when the Earth became round. Now, the Earth was never flat, but we thought it was. So we had that model, that misunderstanding that we all functioned according to.
And once we knew it was round, everything changed. Everything. The flat Earth was a man-made idea. The round Earth was beyond a man-made idea. It was the truth. So things that were logical and important and relevant for a flat Earth were not logical and important or relevant for a round one.
In the world of the flat Earth, there were dangers, the most obvious of which was the edge. If people, if the wind blew, a storm came up, you could be swept over the edge and doomed as a sailor. Sailors navigated within sight of land because they knew that at least the edge wasn't near here. They crippled navigation and exploration. You had to have lookouts posted 24/7, scanning the horizon for the edge.
And you had to have anchors. There was a big anchor business in those days. Huge anchors. And several huge anchors were necessary because as the edge approached, the ship needed to be stabilized immediately. Elsewise, with the force of the edge, it would be easy to sweep the ship and its contents and people over the edge. Now, when the Earth was round, or when the Earth was discovered to be round, all of that, the lookouts, the anchors, the edge issues, all of those things immediately became irrelevant, unnecessary, uninteresting.
There were other things that were relevant and important, and those came into play and came into human behavior.
03Two statements, and one isn't true08:11
So there's something about this example of flat Earth, round Earth that I want to draw upon to illuminate my point that pertains in exactly the same way as where we are as a civilization today about thought and feeling. I'm going to put two statements up on the board. The first statement: feelings are coming from what is happening to us. Okay? Second statement: feelings are coming from our thinking about what is happening to us.
Now, I want you to reflect on those two statements and look at them, because one of those statements is not true. Can you see which one is not true? When I first saw which one of those statements was not true, it changed me. It affected me. It helped me.
It stirred something inside of me. It reminded me of something that I knew to be true. But when I saw what wasn't true, it really helped. Now, what's not true, of course, is that feelings are coming from what's happening to us. That is a different logic than feelings are coming from our thinking about what's happening to us.
One is different from the other, and they're logically inconsistent. Now, until I saw that one of them was not true, I held both of them to be actual. I held both of them to be true. They were—everyone I knew acted as though both of those statements were true: my parents, my neighbors, my colleagues, my fellow students, my friends, the people on the news. Everyone functioned in a world where those two statements were both true.
Now, when I saw that one of them wasn't true, that really meant something to me. I kind of weeded something out that had been alive and well in my experience of life, and it threw me into a moment and an insight, really. It was an insight. It threw me into an insight, a reflective truth that really spoke to me, that my feelings were coming from my thinking about what's happening, not directly from what's happening.
And that, every time I've seen that truth since, every time I've weeded out what was not true and kind of like brought into focus what was true. And separated that from what wasn't true. Every time, every time, it's been helpful to me.
04Where suffering begins11:56
With this next visual, you'll see that I've put both of those statements on the right side of that diagram. And I've put the other statement on the left side of the diagram, that my feelings are coming from my thinking in the moment, just to state it succinctly. All right? And above both of those columns, I drew a line between those because there is a logical inconsistency between the left side of that diagram and the right, and I want you to really see what I mean by that.
That's why above on the visual to the left, I put “One Way.” And above the visual on the right, I've put “Two Ways.” When I saw that there was a logical inconsistency between those two, I saw my own psychological illogic. And I started to see the psychological illogic of my fellow human beings, that it was illogical that it worked both ways. And again, every time I saw that, every time I saw that insightfully, I don't mean just intellectually.
I mean I really took it in and realized the truth of that. It was helpful to me. It woke me up. One way on the left side of the diagram, thought was included in reality. In experience, in feeling.
And on the right side, thought was sometimes not included. That is not true. And seeing what wasn't true, it woke me up to what was. It did something for me, and it's done something for everyone I've ever known who's ever seen that truth. And it will do something for you too, guaranteed, because something that's true that you discover, it's like a North Star for you. It's like an experiential referent.
It's a centering. It's a wake-up. It's a meaningful moment. It's a moment of truth. Any time you have such an experience, it's of value to you, and it's helpful to you, and it does something for you profound. There are many, many, many important implications to this truth that I'm positing right here in this very, very simple way.
They're very practical, very real, very significant for you and for anyone. And I want to talk about this truth, this preexisting truth of this relationship of thought to feeling that is like this. They're together. They are always together. We can artificially separate them like we artificially believed in a flat Earth.
Even though it wasn't true. And that illogic, when we break with that logic and go to illogic, there's a Pandora's box of issues and ills and confusions that we subject ourselves to. Sometimes we bring it together and sometimes we break it apart. Whenever we break it apart, the illogic rules.
And where that illogic starts is where your suffering begins. And where that illogic is resolved, once again, your suffering ends. So it's a very important point, and it's black and white. It's moment to moment. Your feelings are coming from your thinking in the moment, or illogically, your feelings have a life of their own. They have some relationship to something other than thinking, your thinking in the moment.
That illogic, that misunderstanding, that misconception exposes you to forces, sensations, experiences that are destabilizing and egotistical in their implications. So I want to talk about what are some of the important implications of this unity of thought and feeling, and what might we have to say about that. So I'm going to point out four, five, six of those implications just to give you an important reference or respect, or begin to deepen your knowledge about the truth of this unity between thought and feeling that's inseparable.
It's inseparable. It's as inseparable, thought and feeling are as inseparable as the round Earth is to us today. That's not going to change. We're not going to go back to a flat Earth or go to a square Earth. We've seen it. We've even seen it from outer space.
We know what it is now.
05Implications, not applications18:03
Now these points that I'm going to make are very important to realize how they're being talked about. These are implications. They are not applications. There's nothing to do about this fact of the unity and the ever-present connection between thought and feeling.
It's a fact. So a fact needs no thought. It doesn't need a belief. It doesn't need any human doing to make it true, just like the Earth's sphere needed no human doing to make it be so. We just had to ascertain it. We had to realize it.
Once it was realized, there were all these automatic implications. Automatic. They were built into the truth of it. So there was nothing that needed to be done by me. There's nothing you can do to make the Earth any less round than it is. There's nothing you can do to separate thought from feeling.
But every time you look, every time you stop, every time you reflect, every time you get an insight into the inseparable nature of thought and feeling, it will help you. And it will help you right in the throes, at times, of where it's most invisible. So right where you, you know, sometimes you see that, but sometimes you don't. And where you don't, that's where you get into binds.
That's where you get into obsessions. That's where you get into reactions. That's where you get into downward spirals. That's where you get into judgment. That's where you get into feeling out of control, feeling overly emotional, overly sad, overly angry, overly upset.
All of those experiences that we're all familiar with, we've all had, are cues as to we've broken with the logic. And when we break with that logic, we deserve what we get. Just like if we were thinking that the Earth was flat suddenly and counted on that and started buying big anchors and looking out for the edge, we deserve what we get. Like we're betraying how the system actually works. And when we do that, we do that at our own peril.
06Regaining our equilibrium21:00
So the implications of a round Earth came with the territory. The implications that I'm talking about here are not applications. They come with this territory. All right? All of these happen simultaneously together.
So they're not like you need to pick one out and try to do that, or pick another one out and try to do that. They co-occur. They co-occur. They're built into the logic of how you psychologically work, the truth of that. Now, one of the things that happened for me, and one of the things that I've seen happen for anyone who had this insight, no matter whether they had it once or they've had it a million times, every time it's been helpful, like I said.
But every time it happened, you know what happened is it took the misunderstanding that they were embroiled in, that they were subject to, that they were experiencing, it took that misunderstanding off their mind. They popped out of their illogic, and they settled down into a logic of where their feelings were actually coming from. They knew where they were coming from. And when you know where they're coming from, you simultaneously know where they're not coming from.
And that's very important to you, very important to anybody. Last night, for example, I had an episode where I was kind of thinking about something and thinking about this and thinking about that, and my wife said to me, “How are you doing?” I said, “Well, not so good.” She said, “Why?” And I said, “Well, I've got this on my mind and that on my mind and this other thing on my mind.”
And she asked me the question. She says, “Well, does it seem to you that your feelings are coming from your thinking, or are they coming from what you're thinking about?” And I laughed because I thought, “That's a really good question.” You know, it's a question that I ask a lot of people all the time. But when she asked it to me, it brought—it woke me up. It brought it back into focus. I thought, I know this is coming not from these issues, not from these problems, not from these dilemmas that I was in a wrangle about. They were coming from my thinking.
My feeling was coming from the thinking I was doing about those issues, and that really helped me. And what happened is I quieted down, because if you think your feelings are coming from somewhere that they're not, it's going to multiply on you, and you're going to have a lot of thinking that you don't need, that's irrelevant and that's unnecessary and illogical and reactive, and you're going to be subject to that. You're going to be experiencing it. So your feelings are telling you in that moment about your thinking.
But if you think it's telling you about what you're thinking about, you'll get lost in it. If you get lost in it, you can't quiet down. You can't, because someone tells you to quiet down when your head is filled up with all these threats, insecurities, and possibilities, you'll say, “Well, why? I can't quiet down. I've got all this on my mind.”
You get the insight of where your feelings are coming from. It is guaranteed it will help you, and you will quiet down. It renders obsolete an incredible array of thinking every time you insightfully see it. So it quiets you down as an effect of understanding, not as something you need to try to quiet down. You can't help but quiet down.
As I started to see more of this, I noticed my wife and I were talking. She said, “You know, I can't believe how quiet my mind is.” I said, “You know, I'm noticing the same thing.” So many things that I used to weigh in on and perseverate on and ruminate on and think about, worry about, a little of this, a little of that, a little kind of judgmentalism, a little kind of reactivity, and it just went away.
It went away because the illogic of where my feeling was actually coming from, it wasn't coming from that content. It was coming from the way I was thinking about that content. And I started to get those little insights, one little here, a little there, five, ten, fifteen, twenty, fifty times a day. And that reset me, and it brought me back to reality, because I was in a fiction. When you're in a fiction and you give fuel to it, it multiplies on you in a hurry, and you get unstable.
You can't help but, because you're—you're going to get insecure because it feels like your feelings are being determined by what's on your mind. It's not, but it looks like that. That is a very important implication of this true logic about where your feelings are actually coming from.
07You can't feel anything you don't think27:04
You know, the wonderful thing about this truth, this logic of the human experience and how it works, there's only one place that you can actually see it. There's only one slice of time, you might say, that it helps you. And you know when that is? It's the present moment.
It's not going to help you theoretically. It's not going to help you about the past or the future. It's going to help you now. It's always now. And when you wake up to that it's always now, you know, people would talk for years, I would hear them say, “Oh, I've got to be more in the now.”
But I didn't know how to get to the now. I didn't know where the now really was. I thought, “That's a good idea, the now.” I've experienced the now before, and I need to get back to it. But I had no logic of the now.
I didn't see, I hadn't made the connection deep enough into this where my feelings were coming from and the value and importance of the present moment in seeing that insight and getting that experience locked in, getting me locked into the now, such that I could breathe there, I could live there, I could visit there more and more frequently. You know what the now does that's really beautiful? For anyone is it makes you appropriate.
It makes you realistic. It makes you be present to your life as it is, without extra fears, doubts, subjectivities, egotisms bothering you or getting in your way. It levels you here. And that's of extreme help to you.
It's of extreme help to anyone. Anyone who's living in the now or walking around in the now, has a moment of being in the now, they really do well because they're not in a fiction. They're not in some other la-la land. They're here, and they're dealing with life such as it really is. That truth does not exist in the past, and it doesn't exist in thinking about the future.
That really started to help me out of my unhealthy preoccupations, my unhealthy states, my unhealthy patterns that were so common to me, I didn't even know I was doing them. And I don't think most of us know that we're in unhealthy patterns when we're in them. We're feeling our thinking. We're just going around feeling our thinking.
We're lost in our thinking. We're experiencing it, and we don't really know that we're in la-la land. It looks like we're in reality, but we're asleep at the wheel. That's really important to wake up. So I more and more began to self-correct. Like I would see, I would catch myself.
I would notice, “Oh boy, wait a minute, where's this feeling coming from? Is it coming from out there, or is it coming from my thinking?” Always the answer was the same: coming from my thinking. My feelings are not coming from anything out there. It's not designed that way.
It doesn't work that way. Not by my not wanting it to work that way. It scientifically doesn't work that way. That really helped me. My feelings are coming from my thinking about out there.
That, that reminded, it showed me something, that I would never have to experience anything that I didn't think. Well, that took a lot. That insight, and you have it again and again and again, it takes a lot of potential risks and threats and renders them moot, because you can't feel anything you don't think. So there's a kind of a safety.
There's a really profound safety in the truth of that, and you begin to resonate with it and be in the present moment with that truth. And that logic starts to really matter to you and help you and settle you down and take risks that you're now entertaining or problems that you're now distracted by. And it resolves them. It gives you the ability to look at the problem.
You can look at it in the present moment, but you don't have to be frightened by it, no matter what it is. You know, people go through unbelievable experiences, as you know, and have poise and rectitude and a kind of health, and they can face death. They can face the death of loved ones.
They can do anything. There's nothing that human beings have ever been exposed to that can determine how they think about it. That's an inside job. And that truth can only be found in the present moment. This truth, how your actual reality is being created moment to moment to moment, very, very significant for any person.
08We're all in the same boat33:38
You know, you know what it shows you is it shows you that another implication, again, not application, but an implication of the truth of that is the truth of separate realities, which eliminates a whole city of thought that I had that other people should think like me, or that they could think like me, or I would want to try to get them to think like me, or do they think like me. There was a lot of thinking involved with that illusion of a kind of world of agreement that we needed to get going here in order to work together, to have a relationship together, to be citizens, to be co-citizens together.
It denied this fundamental truth about how people were feeling what they're feeling according to their thinking. And when I got in touch with that, it really, it took a lot— again, it took an unbelievable amount of effort and energy off my mind. And I quit thinking about trying to figure out what other people were thinking about. For example, I got respect for how this system worked.
It was marvelous. It was interesting. I saw great, I got great compassion for people. My feelings for people just went through the roof. My heart went out to people. My connection to people really increased dramatically because I realized that we were all in the same boat, and it was a beautiful boat.
You know, I mean, it was a true boat. It doesn't even have to be beautiful. It was true. There was a way that it worked, and we were all party to it, whether we knew it or not, we were party to it. And it reminded me of something, something greater that I had lost track of, that I didn't have the kind of awe about or respect about.
And it brought that back, and it continues to bring it back.
09Facing life as it is36:20
Another implication. It's—now it's far easier for me, and far easier for anyone who's understood this psycho-logic of how we work. It's far easier to deal with and face the truth. My wife likes to say, “You can handle the truth.” I didn't need to be an ostrich.
You know, the ostrich who sticks his head in the sand, “La, la, la, la,” and hope things go away. I didn't have to be a positive thinker. I didn't have to try to think differently. I started to see I had a way to make sense of my life through insight. I started to get prone to insight because all of this other extraneous humdrum noise got subtracted.
I got more open and reflective, and I got out of my world rather than stuck in my world. And that opened me up for seeing larger truths, greater possibilities, greater poise. And I could see my life and what was up and not be trying to positive think about it or positive feel about it. I could look at it objectively. I got more objective.
And anyone that I've known who's understood this has become more and more objective and less, simultaneously, less and less subjective. So they start to become more dealing with actual reality rather than a fictional reality that they were making up in their minds and in their heads and trying to think about this and not think about that, all of which created a busyness in me and in them that subtracted from their presence and from their quiet and from their truth. That they can look at life and they can face life.
It's easier to face the realities of life if your mind is in the present moment and you're not thinking about you want it to be something different and you hate it and you don't like it or you're frustrated by it. That feeling that you're being frustrated by life, that you're feeling a frustration, this is a good example when people say, “That frustrates me. I hate that.” They're telling you how they're feeling, and they're telling you, or telling anyone, or telling themselves, whether they can hear themselves or not, they're telling you how they're thinking about that thing, not the thing. The thing doesn't bring the feeling.
It's the thinking that they have that's bringing the feeling that they have. That's the truth. It cannot be changed, but it can be respected and more and more deeply understood.
10A psychological North Star39:56
Truth is powerful. Truth is helpful. It changes you. You don't know how to predict how much you can be helped by the power of something that's true. You have no idea. It brings you something, and then it brings you more.
And you can't predict. You can't know now what will be brought to you by that. You don't have to know. You can't know, because it's more than what you can imagine, you know, now. So you don't have to think about it. You don't have to know anything about that.
You know that saying that the truth shall set you free. It's really true. But you don't know what freedom you might, what freedoms you might realize tomorrow or the next day or five years from now that you can't imagine that you have now. Not freedom from the world, but freedom to experience the world in a new way, to learn, to change, to evolve. This will quicken your development because you're actually looking toward how reality is actually being created.
You're respecting that. You're grateful for that. You're open to that. You're enjoying that, and that will feed you. And you have, and it's unpredictable what that will do for you.
You are living in the feeling of your thinking. I am, you are, everybody you know is, and that's true. That truth will speak to the very heart of you. And it's a truth that you already know, but it's what distracts you from that, what keeps you doubting it or obsessing about something else that pulls you away from it.
You get more respect for that. You will realize this preexisting logic that I'm pointing to, this logic of this connection between your thought and your feeling in the moment is a, it's a constant. It doesn't change. It can't change. Positive or negative feeling, it doesn't matter.
It's not the type of feeling or the type of thinking. It's the connection. It's the truth of the connection that is a logic that is unusurpable, immutable, inseparable. It's true, and no one will ever change that. So you find something of that order.
You've found what I call a North Star. You find something that's a psychological North Star. You might forget to take a reading on it, like the sailors might in the day when they read by the North Star. But if you stop and take a reading. It's true, and it will guide you because it's a truth that cannot be lost.
It can be forgotten, but it can't be lost. It can be denied, but it's always here. So that's wonderful and important and deserves to be told.
So this is a description, not a prescription, but a description.
It's a constant of why people feel what they feel.
Every time anybody sees such a constant, it speaks to them.
You're going to connect rather than disconnect.
Now, the Earth was never flat, but we thought it was.
The flat Earth was a man-made idea. The round Earth was beyond a man-made idea.
When I first saw which one of those statements was not true, it changed me.
We can artificially separate them like we artificially believed in a flat Earth.
Where the illogic starts is where your suffering begins.
These are implications. They are not applications.
It doesn't need any human doing to make it true, just like the Earth's sphere needed no human doing to make it be so.
When you know where they're coming from, you simultaneously know where they're not coming from.
It quiets you down as an effect of understanding, not as something you need to try to quiet down.
That truth does not exist in the past, and it doesn't exist in thinking about the future.
It looks like we're in reality, but we're asleep at the wheel.
My feelings for people just went through the roof.
I realized that we were all in the same boat, and it was a beautiful boat.
I didn't have to be a positive thinker.
I started to see I had a way to make sense of my life through insight.
Not freedom from the world, but freedom to experience the world in a new way, to learn, to change, to evolve.
That truth will speak to the very heart of you.
It can be forgotten, but it can't be lost.
Lines that state the principles, true in any context.
my feelings were coming from my thinking about what's happening, not directly from what's happening.
My feelings are coming from my thinking about out there.
Your feelings are coming from your thinking in the moment, or illogically, your feelings have a life of their own.
thought and feeling are as inseparable as the round Earth is to us today.
There's nothing you can do to separate thought from feeling.
Your feelings are telling you in that moment about your thinking.
We're just going around feeling our thinking.
you can't feel anything you don't think.
There's nothing that human beings have ever been exposed to that can determine how they think about it.
The thing doesn't bring the feeling. It's the thinking that they have that's bringing the feeling that they have.
You are living in the feeling of your thinking.
It's not the type of feeling or the type of thinking. It's the connection.